Ranked #1
E004 Amy Mihaljevic
E004 Amy Mihaljevic
Amy Mihaljevic loved her family very much. It was that very love, specifically for her mother, that someone sinister pre... Read more
26 Dec 2019
•
55mins
Ranked #2
E006 Laureen Rahn
E006 Laureen Rahn
A New Hampshire teen's Spring Break transformed from what could have been a fun-filled week to one of horror for her mot... Read more
9 Jan 2020
•
44mins
Ranked #3
E014 Gary Grant, Jr.
E014 Gary Grant, Jr.
Gary Grant, Jr. was only seven years old when his life was tragically taken. Thrown out confessions, haunting messages, ... Read more
27 Feb 2020
•
56mins
Ranked #4
E013 Blair Adams
E013 Blair Adams
Blair was seeking protection from… something. It was a trip that would take many false starts and lead to unexplainable ... Read more
20 Feb 2020
•
46mins
Ranked #5
E011 Elisa Lam
E011 Elisa Lam
College student Elisa Lam left for a west coast trip to unwind, but her disappearance (in addition to the bizarre final ... Read more
6 Feb 2020
•
55mins
Ranked #6
E019: Dorothy Jane Scott
E019: Dorothy Jane Scott
He knew intimate personal details about her. He knew where she was at all times. He said he loved Dorothy Jane Scott. Bu... Read more
2 Apr 2020
•
19mins
Ranked #7
E016 Cynthia Anderson
E016 Cynthia Anderson
Cynthia Anderson was having troubling nightmares, receiving upsetting messages, answering obscene phone calls, and worry... Read more
12 Mar 2020
•
58mins
Ranked #8
E005 The Keddie Murders
E005 The Keddie Murders
Keddie had represented hope for the Sharp family (a single mother and her five children)-- hope that they could escape t... Read more
2 Jan 2020
•
1hr 14mins
Ranked #9
E017: The Cheshire Murders
E017: The Cheshire Murders
It was an average summer day for the Petit family in Cheshire, Connecticut--beach trips, golf, and a grocery store outin... Read more
19 Mar 2020
•
21mins
Ranked #10
E015 Abby Williams and Libby German
E015 Abby Williams and Libby German
Heroism and resistance take many forms-- including the use of social media. In this week’s episode, Maggie and Allison e... Read more
5 Mar 2020
•
48mins
Ranked #11
E018 The Bricca Family Murders
E018 The Bricca Family Murders
Was this the outcome of a sordid love triangle, a serial killer, or a calculated mob hit that resulted in the murder of ... Read more
26 Mar 2020
•
30mins
Ranked #12
E008 The USS Cyclops
E008 The USS Cyclops
German captains, added sailors, and electronic fog--oh my! The case Maggie and Allison bring you this week explores the ... Read more
23 Jan 2020
•
36mins
Ranked #13
E007 Virginia Douglas
E007 Virginia Douglas
The case of Virginia Douglas is an odd one. Not only do we not know where she is nor what happened to her, we don't even... Read more
16 Jan 2020
•
48mins
Ranked #14
E010 Diane Augat
E010 Diane Augat
In this episode, Allison and Maggie bring you the story of Diane Augat, a woman who is still missing 22 years after her ... Read more
3 Feb 2020
•
32mins
Ranked #15
E009 Brandon Lawson
E009 Brandon Lawson
What happens when the father of your children disappears? What do you tell them to explain why even Santa isn’t magical ... Read more
30 Jan 2020
•
1hr 6mins
Ranked #16
E003 Dyatlov Pass Part 2
E003 Dyatlov Pass Part 2
When a group of highly-educated, highly-dedicated friends decided to hike Kholat Syakhl they never would have guessed th... Read more
19 Dec 2019
•
1hr 7mins
Ranked #17
E012 The Jamison Family
E012 The Jamison Family
In this week’s episode, Maggie and Allison explore the mysterious deaths of 44-year-old Bobby, 40-year-old Sherilyn, and... Read more
13 Feb 2020
•
51mins
Ranked #18
E025: Message to Our Listeners
E025: Message to Our Listeners
While we do have some bad news for this week, MAKE SURE you listen to our message for some exciting news about next week... Read more
14 May 2020
•
3mins
Ranked #19
E024 The Pollock Twins
E024 The Pollock Twins
The story of the Pollock twins has fascinated the world with the question of reincarnation. Could the spirits of Joanna ... Read more
7 May 2020
•
38mins
Ranked #20
E023: The Walker Family
E023: The Walker Family
When a bloody shoe is left behind at the scene of a crime, we hope that justice will come quickly, especially in a quadr... Read more
30 Apr 2020
•
31mins