Ranked #1
Lindsay Buziak
Lindsay Buziak
Episode 3 Lindsay Buziak On February 2nd 2008, a 24 year old Canadian real estate agent named Lindsay Buziak was murder... Read more
14 Jul 2018
•
58mins
Ranked #2
Liberty German and Abigail Williams -The Delphi Murders
Liberty German and Abigail Williams -The Delphi Murders
Episode 6 Liberty German and Abigail Williams In February, 2017 two teenage girls vanished in the small town of Delphi ... Read more
4 Aug 2018
•
53mins
Ranked #3
Molly Bish
Molly Bish
Episode 40 Molly Bish Sixteen year-old Molly Bish went missing from her lifeguard post at a secluded pond in Warren, Ma... Read more
20 Jul 2019
•
1hr 28mins
Ranked #4
Michael and Linda Holmes
Michael and Linda Holmes
Episode 4 Michael & Linda Holmes The August, 1992 murders of Michael & Linda Holmes at their Indianapolis resid... Read more
21 Jul 2018
•
43mins
Ranked #5
Melissa Missy Taylor Ellison
Melissa Missy Taylor Ellison
Episode 51 Melissa 'Missy' Taylor Ellison In this episode, we discuss the case of 20 year old Melissa Taylor Ellison, b... Read more
21 Dec 2019
•
47mins
Ranked #6
The Pelley Family Murders
The Pelley Family Murders
Episode 42 The Pelley Family Murders In April, 1989, the shocking murders of Bob, Dawn, Janel, and Jolene Pelley shocke... Read more
17 Aug 2019
•
52mins
Ranked #7
Anita Taylor
Anita Taylor
Episode 47 Anita Taylor In October, 1966 twenty year-old wife and mother, Anita Taylor was brutally raped and murdered ... Read more
26 Oct 2019
•
48mins
Ranked #8
Sydney Land
Sydney Land
Episode 25 Sydney Land 21 year-old Sydney Land was shot to death alongside her boyfriend in Las Vegas in October, 2016.... Read more
19 Jan 2019
•
46mins
Ranked #9
Elizabeth Collins and Lyric Cook
Elizabeth Collins and Lyric Cook
Episode 49 Elizabeth Collins and Lyric Cook In July, 2012, Cousins Eight year old Elizabeth Collins, and Ten Year old L... Read more
23 Nov 2019
•
55mins
Ranked #10
Gary and Stephanie Gillette
Gary and Stephanie Gillette
Episode 32 Gary and Stephanie Gillette In December, 1985, Gary and Stephanie Gillette were brutally murdered in their C... Read more
30 Mar 2019
•
1hr 1min
Ranked #11
Matthew Dane
Matthew Dane
Matthew Dane Episode 56 When 19 year-old Air Force Crew Chief, and newlywed Matthew Dane is found murdered outside of La... Read more
7 Mar 2020
•
53mins
Ranked #12
Skip and Joni Tillman
Skip and Joni Tillman
Episode 53 Skip and Joni Tillman Skip & Joni Tillman were found strangled to death in a shallow grave in Southern, ... Read more
26 Jan 2020
•
1hr 6mins
Ranked #13
Ryan McCall
Ryan McCall
Episode 52 Ryan McCall 21 year-old Ryan McCall was shot to death in Tampa, Florida in 2009 during a robbery as he was wa... Read more
11 Jan 2020
•
52mins
Ranked #14
Michael Paul Burke
Michael Paul Burke
Episode 46 Michael Paul Burke In March, 2019, Michael Paul Burke was murdered in Florida by the estranged husband of th... Read more
12 Oct 2019
•
41mins
Ranked #15
Donna Jean Awcock
Donna Jean Awcock
Episode 23 Donna Jean Awcock This episode is about Donna Jean Awcock, a 17 year-old girl who was beaten, raped, and str... Read more
5 Jan 2019
•
36mins
Ranked #16
April Marie Tinsley
April Marie Tinsley
Episode 16 April Marie Tinsley 8 Year-Old April Marie Tinsley was abducted, raped, and murdered in Fort Wayne, IN in 198... Read more
27 Oct 2018
•
41mins
Ranked #17
Melanie Meleney
Melanie Meleney
Episode 50 Melanie Meleney In October, 2018, Melanie Meleney a 45 year-old mother and grandmother, vanished from her Gl... Read more
7 Dec 2019
•
38mins
Ranked #18
Lauria Bible and Ashley Freeman
Lauria Bible and Ashley Freeman
Episode 37 Lauria Bible and Ashley Freeman In December, 1999, Two Oklahoma 16 year-olds Lauria Bible and Ashley Freeman... Read more
8 Jun 2019
•
53mins
Ranked #19
Mary Henderson Morris
Mary Henderson Morris
Episode 36 Mary Henderson Morris Early on the morning Of October 12th, 2000, a 48 year old wife and mother named Mar... Read more
25 May 2019
•
1hr 4mins
Ranked #20
Scott Sampson
Scott Sampson
Episode 30 Scott Sampson 26-year old Scott Sampson was stabbed to death outside of a Portland, Maine store in November,... Read more
23 Feb 2019
•
41mins