Ranked #1
E92: The Bennington Triangle
E92: The Bennington Triangle
The Bennington Triangle in Vermont has historically been home to some of the country's weirdest sightings and events. Th... Read more
12 Jan 2020
•
1hr 31mins
Ranked #2
E42: JFK Assassination (Part One)
E42: JFK Assassination (Part One)
President John Fitzgerald Kennedy ushered in an era of hope in the United States, working to mend relations with the Sov... Read more
19 Nov 2018
•
1hr 42mins
Ranked #3
E49: Death of JFK Jr.
E49: Death of JFK Jr.
John F. Kennedy Jr. was at one time one of the most popular men in Manhattan, working his way through law school and beg... Read more
28 Jan 2019
•
1hr 15mins
Ranked #4
E50: FEMA Camps (Redux)
E50: FEMA Camps (Redux)
Conspiracy theories about FEMA Camps have existed for decades, with believers warning that Americans who are deemed to b... Read more
4 Feb 2019
•
1hr 10mins
Ranked #5
E66: The Sodder Children
E66: The Sodder Children
Christmas 1945 began much like any other holiday for the Sodder family. The boys worked with their father during the day... Read more
3 Jun 2019
•
1hr 2mins
Ranked #6
E61: The Death of Adolf Hitler
E61: The Death of Adolf Hitler
By 1945, Nazi Germany had seen two years of increasing losses on the Eastern front, the involvement of the United States... Read more
29 Apr 2019
•
1hr 42mins
Ranked #7
E86: The Lost Colony of Roanoke
E86: The Lost Colony of Roanoke
In March 1584, Queen Elizabeth I granted a charter to Sir Humphrey Gilbert, allowing him to explore and settle areas of ... Read more
18 Nov 2019
•
1hr 36mins
Ranked #8
E83: The Exorcism of Anneliese Michel
E83: The Exorcism of Anneliese Michel
On July 1st, 1976, 23-year old Anneliese Michel died in her home after having gone through 67 exorcism sessions over a t... Read more
28 Oct 2019
•
1hr 47mins
Ranked #9
E47: Jimmy Hoffa
E47: Jimmy Hoffa
Jimmy Hoffa, former leader of the International Brotherhood of Teamsters, was at one point considered by Attorney Genera... Read more
14 Jan 2019
•
1hr 25mins
Ranked #10
E33: 9/11 (Part Two)
E33: 9/11 (Part Two)
In the second part of our very special two part episode, Matt and Kayla take on the many (many) 9/11 conspiracy theories... Read more
17 Sep 2018
•
1hr 51mins
Ranked #11
E51: Michael and Suzan Bear Carson
E51: Michael and Suzan Bear Carson
Michael and Suzan Bear Carson, two vagabonds living the hippie lifestyle in 1980's California, undertook one of the most... Read more
11 Feb 2019
•
1hr 5mins
Ranked #12
E15: Time Cube Theory
E15: Time Cube Theory
The Big, If True Podcast investigates the curious case of the Time Cube Theory and the father of cubism, Dr. Gene Ray. A... Read more
23 Apr 2018
•
2hr 3mins
Ranked #13
E62: The Great Amherst Mystery
E62: The Great Amherst Mystery
The Great Amherst Mystery is one of Canada's most famous hauntings, and has been cited as being one of the most credible... Read more
6 May 2019
•
1hr 25mins
Ranked #14
E82: The Circleville Letters
E82: The Circleville Letters
In the mid-late 1970's, residents of Circleville, Ohio began to receive disturbing anonymous letters with deeply persona... Read more
21 Oct 2019
•
1hr 31mins
Ranked #15
E65: The Myrtles Plantation
E65: The Myrtles Plantation
Built by Whiskey Rebellion figurehead General David Bradford in 1796, the Myrtles Plantation has a very long and interes... Read more
27 May 2019
•
1hr 23mins
Ranked #16
E94: Bog Bodies + Floating Feet
E94: Bog Bodies + Floating Feet
For hundreds of years, well-preserved bodies of ancient humans have been found in the bogs of northern Europe. These bod... Read more
27 Jan 2020
•
1hr 15mins
Ranked #17
E73: William Patrick Fyfe
E73: William Patrick Fyfe
William Patrick Fyfe, more famously known as the "Killer Handyman", terrorized the city of Montreal over a twenty year p... Read more
29 Jul 2019
•
1hr 9mins
Ranked #18
E67: Michael Jackson (Part One)
E67: Michael Jackson (Part One)
Michael Jackson stands as one of history's most legendary musicians. His legacy is one of innovation, style, philanthrop... Read more
10 Jun 2019
•
1hr 37mins
Ranked #19
E55: Project MKUltra
E55: Project MKUltra
During the early years of the Cold War, the American intelligence community became extremely interested in the raw power... Read more
11 Mar 2019
•
1hr 33mins
Ranked #20
E22: Bermuda Triangle
E22: Bermuda Triangle
The Big, If True Podcast takes on the legend of the Bermuda Triangle, a triangular area in the Atlantic Ocean with point... Read more
18 Jun 2018
•
1hr 27mins