Ranked #1
New Jersey: William "Tim" Durham and Karen Welch
New Jersey: William "Tim" Durham and Karen Welch
This week we’re in New Jersey discussing a terrifying story of cat and mouse…ending in death. Then we’ll talk about how ... Read more
14 Aug 2023
•
1hr
Ranked #2
Wacky Wednesday 40
Wacky Wednesday 40
In today's episode, Ashley tells us about a very depraved man in Russia who collects "dolls." Then, Lacey talks about a ... Read more
9 Aug 2023
•
27mins
Ranked #3
Washington: Teresa Butz, Jennifer Hopper, and Mandy Stavik
Washington: Teresa Butz, Jennifer Hopper, and Mandy Stavik
This week we’re in Washington discussing a murder solved by two moms at a swimming pool. Then, we’ll talk about how a Se... Read more
7 Aug 2023
•
53mins
Ranked #4
Wacky Wednesday 39
Wacky Wednesday 39
In today's episode, Ashley tells us how a flea bite caused a man to lose his limbs. Then, Lacey talks about a rogue tree... Read more
2 Aug 2023
•
32mins
Ranked #5
Virginia: Morgan Harrington, Hannah Graham, and Henrietta Lacks
Virginia: Morgan Harrington, Hannah Graham, and Henrietta Lacks
This week we’re in Virginia discussing the Back to School killer. Then we’ll talk about one of the most important people... Read more
31 Jul 2023
•
52mins
Ranked #6
Wacky Wednesday 38
Wacky Wednesday 38
In today's episode, we discuss a wayward sea otter that is sick and tired of surfers and kayakers. Do you blame her? The... Read more
26 Jul 2023
•
30mins
Ranked #7
Michigan: The Grindr Cannibal and Aundria Bowman
Michigan: The Grindr Cannibal and Aundria Bowman
This week we’re in Michigan discussing the Grindr cannibal. Then we’ll talk about a teenager who vanished under mysterio... Read more
24 Jul 2023
•
1hr 2mins
Ranked #8
Wacky Wednesday 37
Wacky Wednesday 37
On this Wacky Wednesday Ashley tells us about a sinister baby name and Lacey shares a story about the scariest place in ... Read more
19 Jul 2023
•
24mins
Ranked #9
California: The Los Feliz Murder Mansion and Tom and Jackie Hawks
California: The Los Feliz Murder Mansion and Tom and Jackie Hawks
This week we’re in California discussing an infamous murder house that went uninhabited for over 50 years. Then, we’ll t... Read more
17 Jul 2023
•
1hr
Ranked #10
Wacky Wednesday 36
Wacky Wednesday 36
On this Wacky Wednesday Ashley will tell us about another drinking challenge that ends in tragedy. Then, Lacey shares a ... Read more
12 Jul 2023
•
28mins