Ranked #1
Episode 190: Grandpa 123
Episode 190: Grandpa 123
Amanda and Sarah get down and dirty with a series of OG ghost stories and one of the worst movies ever made. Sarah cover... Read more
3 Aug 2023
•
1hr 18mins
Ranked #2
From The Archives: Frogppelgängers
From The Archives: Frogppelgängers
Originally posted as Episode 91 on Feb. 20, 2020. Amanda and Sarah say screw it and try to scare the crap out of each o... Read more
20 Jul 2023
•
1hr 6mins
Similar Podcasts
Morbid
Fake Ritual
My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark
Criminal
A Funny Feeling
Noble Blood
Neon Brainiacs (80s Horror Podcast)
Horror Queers
The Moth
Behind the Bastards
SmartLess
99% Invisible
Dead Meat Podcast
Consider This from NPR
The Daily
Ranked #3
Episode 189: President Boo-lidge
Episode 189: President Boo-lidge
Amanda and Sarah get their heads in the summer vacation game with spooky travel stories and beer. Amanda vets a few tale... Read more
6 Jul 2023
•
1hr 2mins
Ranked #4
Episode 188: Neph-universe with the Neon Brainiacs
Episode 188: Neph-universe with the Neon Brainiacs
Amanda and Sarah are joined by Ben, Gregg, and Lance of Neon Brainiacs for a special fifth-anniversary show! Hear a spo... Read more
22 Jun 2023
•
1hr 8mins
Most Popular Podcasts
The Joe Rogan Experience
TED Talks Daily
The Tim Ferriss Show
The Daily
Stuff You Should Know
Oprah's SuperSoul Conversations
Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard
Ranked #5
Episode 187: The Devil’s Milk Caps
Episode 187: The Devil’s Milk Caps
Amanda and Sarah head to historic New England and back to California for two wild cases. Sarah covers Elizabeth Knapp, a... Read more
8 Jun 2023
•
1hr 18mins
Ranked #6
Episode 186: Born To Sleaze
Episode 186: Born To Sleaze
Amanda and Sarah go goblin mode for this episode about another little fucker and a Hollywood true crime case. Sarah talk... Read more
25 May 2023
•
1hr 7mins
Ranked #7
Episode 185: Final Sale Friend
Episode 185: Final Sale Friend
Amanda and Sarah choose a neutral color palette for two stories about a folkloric crone and mysterious light. Sarah goes... Read more
11 May 2023
•
1hr 3mins
Ranked #8
From The Archives: Balls And Pall Malls
From The Archives: Balls And Pall Malls
Amanda and Sarah revisit an episode from back when they were still figuring out this whole podcasting thing and didn't h... Read more
27 Apr 2023
•
1hr 15mins
Ranked #9
Episode 184: Cradle To The Table
Episode 184: Cradle To The Table
Amanda and Sarah explore some unusual lore and a California cryptid. Sarah says no to drugs with a look at connections b... Read more
13 Apr 2023
•
1hr 16mins
Ranked #10
Episode 183: Screamface
Episode 183: Screamface
Amanda and Sarah sprinkle some spooky potpourri and film facts all over this episode. Sarah samples various Black Dog st... Read more
31 Mar 2023
•
1hr 19mins
