Ranked #1
Listener Short Stack 12
Listener Short Stack 12
You wrote it, we read it! In this Listener Short Stack we get a letter from a new penpal! We also get some theories abou... Read more
27 Feb 2020
•
27mins
Ranked #2
Dad's Mad S2E8
Dad's Mad S2E8
This episode is a saddy, honeys. Karlin covers the maybe-not-so-mysterious death of Sonny Liston. Eliza recounts the bit... Read more
9 Dec 2019
•
1hr 33mins
Similar Podcasts
Unsolved Mysteries
The Trail Went Cold
The Vanished Podcast
Trace Evidence
Unresolved
Already Gone
The Generation Why Podcast
Unsolved Mysteries of the World
Strange and Unexplained with Daisy Eagan
The Minds of Madness - True Crime Stories
MURDERISH
Anatomy of Murder
True Crime Chronicles
Southern Fried True Crime
Casefile True Crime
Ranked #3
Totally Nake S2E2
Totally Nake S2E2
Alison covers the mysterious death of Jack Brown. Karlin gets a biiiiit skeptical about the Blinking Jesus at Holy Trini... Read more
16 Sep 2019
•
1hr 18mins
Ranked #4
Satan in a Shoebox S2E7
Satan in a Shoebox S2E7
In S2E7 Alison theorizes that Rhonda Hinson’s murderer is actually pretty obvious and wonders why UM didn’t give the who... Read more
25 Nov 2019
•
2hr 6mins
Most Popular Podcasts
The Joe Rogan Experience
TED Talks Daily
The Tim Ferriss Show
The Daily
Stuff You Should Know
Oprah's SuperSoul Conversations
Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard
Ranked #5
Saucer-stansive Evidence S2E1
Saucer-stansive Evidence S2E1
It's our Season Two Premier! Karlin tells a tale of lost love—soldier Jim Meade Jr. has been searching 15 years for nurs... Read more
2 Sep 2019
•
1hr 42mins
Ranked #6
Between the Folds S2E6
Between the Folds S2E6
Did Rudolph Hess escape? Did he die by suicide? Was he murdered? Eliza, does some Nazi hunting to find out. Alison cover... Read more
15 Nov 2019
•
1hr 40mins
Ranked #7
Poopin' in His Little Police Pants S2E4
Poopin' in His Little Police Pants S2E4
Karlin provides an update on fugitive Greg Webb a full-on garbage person who murdered Anna Marie Anton, a woman who may ... Read more
14 Oct 2019
•
1hr 37mins
Ranked #8
Marfa, Marfa, Marfa! S2E5
Marfa, Marfa, Marfa! S2E5
Sure, Jan. Alison covers the cases of Dale Kerstetter and the missing platinum, was he an unwitting victim or did he pla... Read more
28 Oct 2019
•
1hr 46mins
Ranked #9
File It Under Puss S1E11
File It Under Puss S1E11
Alison releases the fury for Jenny Pratt and rails against the selfish, entitled SoCal community that has continued to w... Read more
21 Jan 2019
•
2hr 40mins
Ranked #10
The Coziest Corpse S1E13
The Coziest Corpse S1E13
Alison covers the murder of Lee Selwyn and laments that she missed her true decade. Eliza dives into yet another WTAF co... Read more
18 Feb 2019
•
1hr 53mins
Ranked #11
For Heaven's Sake! S2E3
For Heaven's Sake! S2E3
Alison covers the mysterious murder of Kay Hall, could the husband have done it?! GASP! Eliza & Robert Stack warn us... Read more
30 Sep 2019
•
1hr 55mins
Ranked #12
Prime Smelling Time S2E9
Prime Smelling Time S2E9
Alison explores the doomed love affair of Maria Armstrong & Ron Argenti. Eliza covers the story of holocaust survivo... Read more
6 Jan 2020
•
1hr 55mins
Ranked #13
Allegedly Allegedly Allegedly S1E12
Allegedly Allegedly Allegedly S1E12
Eliza has not one but two lost loves and they're both super good (we can't believe it either!) so she's not too mad abou... Read more
4 Feb 2019
•
2hr 20mins
Ranked #14
Literally Cutthroat S1E16
Literally Cutthroat S1E16
Karlin tells us a tale of possible police corruption and the theories surrounding the murder of Lester Garnier. Eliza di... Read more
15 Apr 2019
•
1hr 50mins
Ranked #15
Surly Reputations S1E21
Surly Reputations S1E21
Karlin tells us the truly harrowing story of Lisa Marie Kimmel and the outrage is real. Eliza is so so so grateful that ... Read more
24 Jun 2019
•
1hr 55mins
Ranked #16
It's for Bonin', Dude! S1E24
It's for Bonin', Dude! S1E24
It’s the Season One Finale, honeys! We have some exciting announcements for you so don’t skip the intro, ya skippies. Al... Read more
5 Aug 2019
•
2hr 19mins
Ranked #17
Foresquin S1E18
Foresquin S1E18
Episode 18 has a little something for everyone. This five segment episode is as big as Bigfoot’s, um... big feet. Eliza ... Read more
16 May 2019
•
2hr 31mins
Ranked #18
Listener Short Stack 1
Listener Short Stack 1
On our very first Listener Short Stack we discuss listener Jamie's call for justice for Amy Mihaljevic, a 29 year old co... Read more
21 Feb 2019
•
18mins
Ranked #19
Who's the Psychic Now?! S1E15
Who's the Psychic Now?! S1E15
Alison gives a bananas update on the case of missing Micki Jo West and we all decide that if you’re going to murder peop... Read more
1 Apr 2019
•
2hr
Ranked #20
Neckerchief and Nips S1E20
Neckerchief and Nips S1E20
Hold on to your cowboy boots because this episode gets truly WILD. In episode 20, Karlin discusses us the sad and confus... Read more
10 Jun 2019
•
1hr 45mins
