Ranked #1
Cults You Can Join Today
Cults You Can Join Today
Adam, Caitlin and Kari discuss creepy cults that are active today. Join now! Also, don't do that last thing we said. Pre... Read more
25 May 2017
•
58mins
Ranked #2
Abducted In Plain Sight
Abducted In Plain Sight
Adam and Caitlin talk to Skye Borgman, producer and director of the insane documentary Abducted In Plain Sight Learn mor... Read more
15 Mar 2019
•
1hr 8mins
Similar Podcasts
You Don't Even Like This Show
Conspiracy! The Show
Gamefully Unemployed
Secretly Incredibly Fascinating
Behind the Bastards
MrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious Stories
Small Beans
Last Podcast On The Left
Strange and Unexplained with Daisy Eagan
Quick Question with Soren and Daniel
Morbid
True Crime Garage
It Could Happen Here
The Dollop with Dave Anthony and Gareth Reynolds
The Generation Why Podcast
Ranked #3
Don't F**k With Cats
Don't F**k With Cats
Adam and Kari discuss a new Netflix documentary that explores the ramifications of internet mob justice Learn more about... Read more
1 Jan 2020
•
1hr 4mins
Ranked #4
Mrs. Doody
Mrs. Doody
Adam, Caitlin and Kari discuss the infamous St. Valentine's Day Massacre. Pretty Scary boo!Learn more about your ad choi... Read more
15 Feb 2017
•
1hr 15mins
Most Popular Podcasts
The Joe Rogan Experience
TED Talks Daily
The Tim Ferriss Show
The Daily
Stuff You Should Know
Oprah's SuperSoul Conversations
Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard
Ranked #5
Amusement Park Disasters
Amusement Park Disasters
Adam and Kari look into some of the most harrowing amusement park ride disasters of all time. Pretty Scary Boo! Learn mo... Read more
23 May 2018
•
1hr 1min
Ranked #6
Murders That Happened On Halloween
Murders That Happened On Halloween
Adam and Kari discuss some of the most notorious crimes to ever happen on Halloween. Pretty Scary boo!Learn more about y... Read more
26 Oct 2017
•
49mins
Ranked #7
The 20 Most Shocking Crimes of the 2010s
The 20 Most Shocking Crimes of the 2010s
Adam and Caitlin count down the most shocking crimes of the past decade. The results may surprise you! Learn more about... Read more
4 Dec 2019
•
1hr 48mins
Ranked #8
Calais
Calais
This week, on a very special episode of Pretty Scary, Adam and Caitlin discuss horror stories from the refugee crisis in... Read more
1 Feb 2017
•
59mins
Ranked #9
The Co-Ed Killer
The Co-Ed Killer
Adam and Caitlin discuss the strange and historic case of Edmund Kemper, more famously known as the Co-Ed Killer. His cr... Read more
2 Nov 2017
•
49mins
Ranked #10
The Battle of the Lizzie Borden House
The Battle of the Lizzie Borden House
Amy Bruni and Adam Berry from the TLC show "Kindred Spirits" join Caitlin, Kari and Adam (Tod Brown) to discuss a possib... Read more
14 Sep 2017
•
49mins
Ranked #11
What Happened To Jennifer Kesse?
What Happened To Jennifer Kesse?
Adam and Kari welcome comedian and friend Jenn Sterger to discuss the strange disappearance of Jennifer Kesse, a Florida... Read more
11 Apr 2018
•
55mins
Ranked #12
The Chicago Tylenol Murders
The Chicago Tylenol Murders
Guest co-host Danger Van Gorder joins Adam and Caitlin to discuss a murder case that changed the over-the-counter pharma... Read more
19 Oct 2017
•
1hr 8mins
Ranked #13
The Effects Of A Nuclear Explosion
The Effects Of A Nuclear Explosion
Adam and Caitlin look into what happens when a nuclear weapon explodes. Pretty Scary boo!Learn more about your ad choice... Read more
20 Jul 2017
•
1hr 1min
Ranked #14
The Golden State Killer
The Golden State Killer
Adam and Kari discuss the Golden State Killer and the insane story behind how he was finally caught. Learn more about yo... Read more
9 May 2018
•
1hr 22mins
Ranked #15
About Ralphie May
About Ralphie May
Adam and Kari talk to filmmaker/comedian Cat Rhinehart about the documentary "What's Eating Ralphie May?" Learn more ab... Read more
30 Oct 2019
•
1hr 7mins
Ranked #16
The Beverly Hills Supper Club Fire (of Cincinnati)
The Beverly Hills Supper Club Fire (of Cincinnati)
Adam and Kari welcome Rich Slaton and Jon Shefsky from the Criiime! Podcast to discuss a tragedy from the past and its u... Read more
12 Oct 2017
•
57mins
Ranked #17
The Chillicothe Six
The Chillicothe Six
Adam and Kari look into the mysterious disappearance of six women in Chillicothe, Ohio between May 2014 and May 2015 Lea... Read more
25 Jul 2018
•
1hr 34mins
Ranked #18
The 5 Most Memorable Murders of 2019
The 5 Most Memorable Murders of 2019
Adam and Kari discuss the deaths Nipsey Hussle, Muhlaysia Booker, Samantha Josephson, and more murders that defined 2019... Read more
23 Oct 2019
•
1hr 6mins
Ranked #19
Ghost Finger
Ghost Finger
Adam, Caitlin, and Kari discuss the strange phenomenon known as ghost sex. What is that? Sex with ghosts, obviously. Giv... Read more
1 Mar 2017
•
1hr 1min
Ranked #20
The Chicago Rippers
The Chicago Rippers
On this episode, we delve into one of the weirdest and most brutal crimes of the '80s ... The Chicago Rippers. Pretty Sc... Read more
17 Jan 2018
•
1hr 2mins
