Ranked #1
S3E8: A Real Page-Turner - Transylvania Book Heist
S3E8: A Real Page-Turner - Transylvania Book Heist
Nate's friend Rachel jumps onto the podcast to help us close out Season 3. Some people will go to great lengths to turn ... Read more
21 Sep 2022
•
29mins
Ranked #2
S3E7: A Bridge Too Far
S3E7: A Bridge Too Far
People will steal anything to make a buck - but even a bridge? Tune in to this week's episode to hear Nate discuss three... Read more
14 Sep 2022
•
33mins
Ranked #3
S3E6: Bloody Bardstown
S3E6: Bloody Bardstown
How on earth can there have been five mysterious deaths in the Bourbon Capital of the world, and no one to answer for th... Read more
7 Sep 2022
•
36mins
Ranked #4
S3E5: Misery - Cheryl Ann Kenney, Angela Hammond, and Trudy Darby
S3E5: Misery - Cheryl Ann Kenney, Angela Hammond, and Trudy Darby
Could three attacks on unsuspecting women in 1991 all have been connected? Nate looks into the cases of Cheryl Ann Kenne... Read more
31 Aug 2022
•
38mins
Most Popular Podcasts
The Joe Rogan Experience
TED Talks Daily
The Tim Ferriss Show
The Daily
Stuff You Should Know
Oprah's SuperSoul Conversations
Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard
Ranked #5
S3E4: The Meaning of The Mound - Great Serpent Mound
S3E4: The Meaning of The Mound - Great Serpent Mound
It's been around since long before we settled into the Ohio Valley, but just how old is it? And who designed it so perfe... Read more
24 Aug 2022
•
33mins
Ranked #6
S3E3: The Red Bicycle - Asenath Dukat
S3E3: The Red Bicycle - Asenath Dukat
Asenath, or "Seenie" Dukat was walking home from school on June 3rd of 1980. When she never came home alive, police fran... Read more
17 Aug 2022
•
44mins
Ranked #7
S3E2: Trucking Chapel Tragedy - Bill and Peggy Stephenson
S3E2: Trucking Chapel Tragedy - Bill and Peggy Stephenson
When a preacher and his wife are found murdered in their Northern Kentucky home, police key in on a number of different ... Read more
10 Aug 2022
•
49mins
Ranked #8
S3E1: Up In Smoke - Beverly Hills Supper Club Fire
S3E1: Up In Smoke - Beverly Hills Supper Club Fire
The Ohio Valley has been home to a number of tragedies since it was settled. None of which may be more impactful and hor... Read more
3 Aug 2022
•
42mins
Ranked #9
Season Three: Bigger, Better, Buckeye-er
Season Three: Bigger, Better, Buckeye-er
Nate gives you a Season 3 update on Mysteries of The Ohio Valley. We promise it'll be worth the wait! Mark your calendar... Read more
4 Jul 2022
•
1min
Ranked #10
S2E22 - Next In Line: The Dumler Family Murders
S2E22 - Next In Line: The Dumler Family Murders
On a brisk October night in 1969, a husband and wife were murdered along with another family member in their upscale Cin... Read more
27 Oct 2021
•
25mins
