Ranked #1
S8 Episode 1: Darlene Messer
S8 Episode 1: Darlene Messer
Darlene Messer was abducted from a Suwannee Swifty store in Lake City Florida on September 18, 1989.MUSIC: Music from ht... Read more
4 Oct 2019
•
57mins
Ranked #2
Season 2: Episode 1 – The Basement
Season 2: Episode 1 – The Basement
Janette Roberson was murdered in the basement pet department of the Gambles store downtown Reed City, Michigan in 1983.I... Read more
2 Mar 2018
•
28mins
Similar Podcasts
Hide and Seek
The Vanished Podcast
Southern Fried True Crime
The Lady Vanishes
Sword and Scale
Cold Case Files
Crime Junkie
You Can’t Make This Up
Root of Evil: The True Story of the Hodel Family and the Black Dahlia
Park Predators
Witnessed: Devil in the Ditch
I Was Never There
The Execution of Bonny Lee Bakley
Project Unabom
Ranked #3
S7: Episode 1 – Little Girl, Lost
S7: Episode 1 – Little Girl, Lost
Cathy Davidson went missing on September 1, 1973 - or did she? MUSIC:Kevin Macleod - incompetechAn Upsetting ThemeGhostp... Read more
19 Jun 2019
•
49mins
Ranked #4
S6: Episode 1 – Who Killed Rick Atwood?
S6: Episode 1 – Who Killed Rick Atwood?
Rick Atwood was last seen in White Cloud, Michigan on August 10, 1983. His Trans-Am was found two months later in Grand ... Read more
28 Jan 2019
•
33mins
Most Popular Podcasts
The Joe Rogan Experience
TED Talks Daily
The Tim Ferriss Show
The Daily
Stuff You Should Know
Oprah's SuperSoul Conversations
Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard
Ranked #5
S11: Episode 1 – The Bomb at the Shop & Go
S11: Episode 1 – The Bomb at the Shop & Go
On December 25th, 1984, 11 year old Paul Jewell rode up to a local convenience store to put air in the tire of a borrowe... Read more
6 Apr 2020
•
33mins
Ranked #6
Season 3: Episode 1 – Give or Walk?
Season 3: Episode 1 – Give or Walk?
This season I will cover the many crimes of an offender named Peter Piper. In this episode, I introduce you to "Mary" an... Read more
6 Jul 2018
•
52mins
Ranked #7
Season 2: Episode 2 – That Day
Season 2: Episode 2 – That Day
In this episode we go through a timeline of customers who were in the store that day and hear from the dispatcher.Down &... Read more
9 Mar 2018
•
39mins
Ranked #8
S9: Episode 1 – Teryl Steele Orcutt
S9: Episode 1 – Teryl Steele Orcutt
On January 21, 1990, Teryl Orcutt's 1989 red 2 door Ford Thunderbird was found abandoned on the side of County Road 218 ... Read more
17 Jan 2020
•
49mins
Ranked #9
S8 Episode 2: The Body
S8 Episode 2: The Body
Two days after Darlene Messer was abducted from the Suwannee Swifty convenience store in Lake City, Florida, her body is... Read more
4 Oct 2019
•
33mins
Ranked #10
S6: Episode 2 – Who Killed Rick Atwood?
S6: Episode 2 – Who Killed Rick Atwood?
Rick Atwood was last seen in White Cloud, Michigan on August 10, 1983. His Trans-Am was found two months later in Grand ... Read more
28 Jan 2019
•
27mins
Ranked #11
Season 5: Episode 2 – The (Other) Body in The (Other) Lake
Season 5: Episode 2 – The (Other) Body in The (Other) Lake
Someone who knew Marvin Gabrion talks about the body that he says he found in Twinwood ("Big Twin") Lake. This would be ... Read more
22 Nov 2018
•
41mins
Ranked #12
S7: Episode 5: Baby K & Brother James
S7: Episode 5: Baby K & Brother James
This episode covers two young victims of Mother Anna, a brother and sister. MUSIC:Evening of Chaos - incompetechStudy Wa... Read more
17 Jul 2019
•
41mins
Ranked #13
S8 Episode 3: Reports
S8 Episode 3: Reports
This episode delves into the medical examiner’s report in Darlene Messer’s case and related police reports where she was... Read more
4 Oct 2019
•
33mins
Ranked #14
S8 Episode 5: Unusual Suspects
S8 Episode 5: Unusual Suspects
More possible suspects investigators pursued in Darlene Messer’s homicide case.FBI Crime Analyst VICAP video:https://www... Read more
4 Oct 2019
•
57mins
Ranked #15
Season 2: Episode 3 – First Responders
Season 2: Episode 3 – First Responders
“Knowledge will forever govern ignorance, and a people who mean to be their own governors, must arm themselves with the ... Read more
16 Mar 2018
•
33mins
Ranked #16
S6: Episode 4 – Who Killed Rick Atwood?
S6: Episode 4 – Who Killed Rick Atwood?
Rick Atwood was last seen in White Cloud Michigan on August 10, 1983. His Trans-Am was found two months later in Grand R... Read more
28 Jan 2019
•
31mins
Ranked #17
S10: Episode 1 – Clermont Florida Jane Doe
S10: Episode 1 – Clermont Florida Jane Doe
On September 25, 1988, the decomposed body of a female was found on county road 474, about halfway between highways 33 a... Read more
1 Feb 2020
•
28mins
Ranked #18
S9: Episode 5 – The Hunter
S9: Episode 5 – The Hunter
Perhaps the most important witness in Teryl Orcutt's murder is discussed in the final episode of the season.*MUSIC CREDI... Read more
17 Jan 2020
•
54mins
Ranked #19
S6: Episode 5 – Who Killed Rick Atwood?
S6: Episode 5 – Who Killed Rick Atwood?
Rick Atwood was last seen in White Cloud, Michigan on August 10, 1983. His Trans-Am was found two months later in Grand ... Read more
28 Jan 2019
•
28mins
Ranked #20
Season 4 – Episode 1: The Murder of Arnold Holmes
Season 4 – Episode 1: The Murder of Arnold Holmes
A simple owner/tenant dispute that ends in murder/suicide isn't quite as simple as it seems.(Episode 1 of 4)MUSIC Blue D... Read more
26 Sep 2018
•
1hr 1min
