Ranked #1
39 - 100 Oranges In
39 - 100 Oranges In
Jade eggs out! This week Tyler and Johnny discuss the strange case of the Collyer Brothers and the infamous Villisca Axe... Read more
3 Jul 2019
•
1hr 27mins
Ranked #2
34 - Elevengendary
34 - Elevengendary
How many licks does it take 'til you get to the center of this mystery? This week, Tyler and Johnny discuss the alien en... Read more
29 May 2019
•
1hr 43mins
Similar Podcasts
Cult Liter with Spencer Henry
OBITCHUARY
The Strange and Unusual Podcast
And That's Why We Drink
Scream!
Morbid
Seven Deadly Sinners
Sinisterhood
Two Girls One Ghost
A Paranormal Chicks
Wine & Crime
My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark
Dark History
The Generation Why Podcast
Supernatural with Ashley Flowers
Ranked #3
36 - Pool Mannequins 2
36 - Pool Mannequins 2
"Look Mom, no hands... Because they're handcuffed behind me!" This week, Johnny and Tyler discuss the haunting of Fox Ho... Read more
12 Jun 2019
•
1hr 21mins
Ranked #4
4 - Lady Bunnyman
4 - Lady Bunnyman
Show us the receipts! On this very special Halloween episode, Johnny and Tyler cover the absurd story of the Sisman-Plat... Read more
31 Oct 2018
•
1hr 26mins
Most Popular Podcasts
The Joe Rogan Experience
TED Talks Daily
The Tim Ferriss Show
The Daily
Stuff You Should Know
Oprah's SuperSoul Conversations
Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard
Ranked #5
44 - Go To Bed, Wig
44 - Go To Bed, Wig
We are doubly blessed today! This week Tyler and Johnny discuss the mac 'n' cheese of paranormal cases, the Haunting in ... Read more
7 Aug 2019
•
1hr 39mins
Ranked #6
29 - Bless This Mess
29 - Bless This Mess
Welcome to the Warrenapalooza! This week, Tyler and Johnny discuss the Smurl Family haunting and the trial of Arne Cheye... Read more
24 Apr 2019
•
1hr 20mins
Ranked #7
60 - Murder Prom
60 - Murder Prom
Hold on to your homemade wig! This week Johnny and Tyler discuss the Beast of Jersey and Soap-Maker of Correggio, Leonar... Read more
4 Dec 2019
•
1hr 17mins
Ranked #8
30 - Hotdog Squad
30 - Hotdog Squad
Hope you like poems! This week Tyler and Johnny discuss the elusive Chupacabra, and one of the biggest wieners of all ti... Read more
1 May 2019
•
1hr 28mins
Ranked #9
17 - Ye Olde McMansion
17 - Ye Olde McMansion
Break out your favourite eatin' dress! This week, Tyler and Johnny cover the little-known cult, the Ant Hill Kids, as we... Read more
30 Jan 2019
•
1hr 40mins
Ranked #10
32 - Stale Cookie
32 - Stale Cookie
Call up your best frenemy! This week, Johnny and Tyler discuss the murder of Angel Melendez (the 'Party Monster' case) a... Read more
15 May 2019
•
1hr 26mins
Ranked #11
5 - Rituale Ray Romano
5 - Rituale Ray Romano
The hills are alive with the sound of NOPE. This week your gay best friends are talking about the Falcon Lake incident a... Read more
7 Nov 2018
•
1hr 6mins
Ranked #12
63 - Psychic Debutante
63 - Psychic Debutante
We're here for frickin' love! This week Tyler and Johnny discuss the Slit-Mouthed Woman (Kuchisake-Onna) and the Baldoon... Read more
26 Dec 2019
•
1hr 24mins
Ranked #13
62 - Live Like a Queen
62 - Live Like a Queen
Get ready for a blow out! This week Johnny and Tyler discuss Krampus and The Cage in Saint Osyth. Plus: extreme embalmin... Read more
18 Dec 2019
•
1hr 10mins
Ranked #14
26 - Pool Mannequins
26 - Pool Mannequins
Get off the desk! This week, Tyler and Johnny cover Hellish Nell, Britain’s last witch, and the king of the pool mannequ... Read more
3 Apr 2019
•
1hr 30mins
Ranked #15
7 - I Got Bangs!
7 - I Got Bangs!
To the oubliette, to the wall! This week Johnny and Tyler recall spooky stories from their childhood: Jerome, The Myster... Read more
21 Nov 2018
•
1hr 31mins
Ranked #16
13 - Just Peachy
13 - Just Peachy
When a little ghost girl tells you something in a dream, do it! This week, Tyler and Johnny cover the infamous cases of ... Read more
2 Jan 2019
•
1hr 23mins
Ranked #17
33 - Good God Get a Grip Girl
33 - Good God Get a Grip Girl
Time to clean the jam off of your hands! This week, Tyler and Johnny discuss the murder of Cassie Jo Stoddart and the le... Read more
22 May 2019
•
1hr 27mins
Ranked #18
35 - Top Hat Mom
35 - Top Hat Mom
Paint your nails and go to bed! This week, Johnny and Tyler read freaky stories submitted by some of you spooky bitches.... Read more
5 Jun 2019
•
1hr 9mins
Ranked #19
56 - Cuckoo For Coconuts
56 - Cuckoo For Coconuts
The Otter Moon has risen! This week Tyler and Johnny discuss the Lobster Boy murders and the Coconut Cult. Plus: Hallowe... Read more
6 Nov 2019
•
1hr 16mins
Ranked #20
16 - Here's The Ti
16 - Here's The Ti
Clutch your Pumpkin Spice Lattes, because we're getting basic! This week, Tyler and Johnny cover the spook house, Villa ... Read more
23 Jan 2019
•
1hr 33mins
