Ranked #1
Episode 288: The Magical Quality of the Magic Box
Episode 288: The Magical Quality of the Magic Box
Peter Fenzel, Mark Lee, and Matthew Wrather overthink Netflix, the Netflix queue, and the phenomenon of movies disappear... Read more
6 Jan 2014
•
Ranked #2
Episode 614: What Is a Tiger? What Does That Even Mean?
Episode 614: What Is a Tiger? What Does That Even Mean?
Support Overthinking It by becoming a member for $5/month! Peter Fenzel, Mark Lee, and Matthew Wrather have strong feeli... Read more
6 Apr 2020
•
Similar Podcasts
We Hate Movies
Behind the Bastards
Judge John Hodgman
How Did This Get Made?
Wait Wait... Don't Tell Me!
Doug Loves Movies
Slate Culture
Dumb People Town
Extra Hot Great: This Week In TV
The Bugle
The Big Picture
99% Invisible
Watch Out for Fireballs!
Factually! with Adam Conover
The Sporkful
Ranked #3
Episode 415: Hamilton Doesn’t Scale
Episode 415: Hamilton Doesn’t Scale
Ben Adams, Mark Lee, and Matthew Wrather talk about what it means for a musical like Hamilton to be a “mass” cultural ph... Read more
13 Jun 2016
•
Ranked #4
Episode 278: The Star Wars Trilogy Isn’t Over Until the Yub Nub Song is Sung
Episode 278: The Star Wars Trilogy Isn’t Over Until the Yub Nub Song is Sung
Matthew Belinkie, Peter Fenzel, Mark, Lee, and Matthew Wrather are joined by Zach Giallongo, writer and illustrator of “... Read more
28 Oct 2013
•
Most Popular Podcasts
The Joe Rogan Experience
TED Talks Daily
The Tim Ferriss Show
The Daily
Stuff You Should Know
Oprah's SuperSoul Conversations
Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard
Ranked #5
Episode 600: This Is How You Make Up Nonsense
Episode 600: This Is How You Make Up Nonsense
Support Overthinking It by becoming a member for $5/month! Peter Fenzel, Mark Lee, and Matthew Wrather count down the 10... Read more
30 Dec 2019
•
Ranked #6
Episode 431: The Zipcodes in the Marvel Netflix World
Episode 431: The Zipcodes in the Marvel Netflix World
Peter Fenzel, Mark Lee, and Matthew Wrather discuss their favorite Sagas, what makes Epic and Saga different, and why un... Read more
3 Oct 2016
•
Ranked #7
Episode 424: Stranger Things: The Horror Is at Home
Episode 424: Stranger Things: The Horror Is at Home
Rachel D, Birthday Boy Peter Fenzel, Ryan Sheely, and Matthew Wrather are joined by guest Sam Reich to overthink Srangte... Read more
15 Aug 2016
•
Ranked #8
Episode 377: A Vin Diesel Solution to a Whitey Bulger Problem
Episode 377: A Vin Diesel Solution to a Whitey Bulger Problem
Peter Fenzel, Mark Lee, and Matthew Wrather overthink favorite villains from our childhood entertainment, the current st... Read more
21 Sep 2015
•
Ranked #9
Episode 379: The Space Program of the 50s, 60s, 70s…and Today
Episode 379: The Space Program of the 50s, 60s, 70s…and Today
Ben Adams, Pete Fenzel, Mark Lee, and Ryan Sheely tackle the science, politics, and music of the Ridley Scott movie The ... Read more
5 Oct 2015
•
Ranked #10
Episode 421: This Is Why We Star Trek
Episode 421: This Is Why We Star Trek
Peter Fenzel, Mark Lee, and Matthew Wrather are joined by former podcast guest Benjamin Krinsky to discuss Star Trek Bey... Read more
25 Jul 2016
•
Ranked #11
Episode 595: Childhood Is Not a Movie for Kids
Episode 595: Childhood Is Not a Movie for Kids
Support Overthinking It by becoming a member for $5/month! Peter Fenzel, Mark Lee, and Matthew Wrather sob through 90% o... Read more
25 Nov 2019
•
Ranked #12
Episode 433: Democracy is the Ultimate Kayfabe
Episode 433: Democracy is the Ultimate Kayfabe
Peter Fenzel, Mark Lee, and Matthew Wrather are joined by special guest Rob Cesternino of “Rob Has A Podcast”, to discus... Read more
17 Oct 2016
•
Ranked #13
Episode 336: Black Mirror – The Pig Effing Trolley Problem
Episode 336: Black Mirror – The Pig Effing Trolley Problem
Matthew Belinkie, Peter Fenzel, Ryan Sheely, and Matthew Wrather are joined by guest podcasters and significant others R... Read more
8 Dec 2014
•
Ranked #14
Episode 320: The Expendables 3: A Midsummer Night’s Railgun
Episode 320: The Expendables 3: A Midsummer Night’s Railgun
Pete Fenzel and Matthew Wrather overthink The Expendables 3, the arc of the Expendables trilogy from self-serious to sel... Read more
18 Aug 2014
•
Ranked #15
Episode 391: Star Wars: A Child Is A Reboot of the Grittiest Sort
Episode 391: Star Wars: A Child Is A Reboot of the Grittiest Sort
Ben Adams, Matt Belinkie, Peter Fenzel, Mark Lee, Ryan Sheely, and Matt Wrather continue their discussion of Star Wars: ... Read more
28 Dec 2015
•
Ranked #16
Episode 310: Standing At The Edge of Tomorrow
Episode 310: Standing At The Edge of Tomorrow
Ben Adams, Pete Fenzel, Mark Lee, Shana Mlawski and Matthew Wrather prepare to tackle Tom Cruise’s latest, Edge of Tomor... Read more
9 Jun 2014
•
Ranked #17
Episode 420: Ghostbusters: Lean In to the Proton Pack
Episode 420: Ghostbusters: Lean In to the Proton Pack
Rachel D, Peter Fenzel, Mark Lee, Ryan Sheely, and Matthew Wrather start a scrappy small business to self-actualize and ... Read more
18 Jul 2016
•
Ranked #18
Episode 488: Thor: Macklemore
Episode 488: Thor: Macklemore
Peter Fenzel, Mark Lee, and Matthew Wrather try desperately to prevent the end of the world as they discuss Thor: Ragnar... Read more
6 Nov 2017
•
Ranked #19
Episode 341: It’s Nice That There are Films That are Ambitious
Episode 341: It’s Nice That There are Films That are Ambitious
Peter Fenzel, Mark Lee, John Perich, and Matthew Wrather overthink contemporary prestige pictures, including Inherent Vi... Read more
12 Jan 2015
•
Ranked #20
Episode 503: The Killmonger Doctrine
Episode 503: The Killmonger Doctrine
Peter Fenzel and Matthew Wrather are joined by the actual people they saw Black Panther with: In LA, Matt and Josh, and ... Read more
19 Feb 2018
•
